Written by Paul Worrall
If you’ve decided to sell prints of your artwork online without holding stock, you’ve almost certainly landed on two names — Printful and Printify. They dominate the print on demand space and both will tell you they’re the best option for artists. Predictably.
The honest answer is that neither is universally better. They’re built around different models and suit different types of artists. After 16 years in digital marketing — including a decade working inside the art supplies industry — I’ve seen artists make expensive mistakes by picking the wrong one without properly understanding the difference.
So let’s settle this properly.
What’s the Actual Difference Between Printful and Printify?
This is where most comparison articles gloss over the thing that matters most.
Printful is a single company. They own their own printing facilities, employ their own staff, and fulfil every order themselves. When something goes wrong there’s one company to call. When quality is inconsistent you know exactly who’s responsible.
Printify is a marketplace. They connect you to a network of third party print providers around the world. You choose which supplier handles your orders. That means more flexibility and often lower prices — but also more variability in quality and a more complex experience when things go wrong.
That fundamental difference flows through into almost every other aspect of the comparison. Keep it in mind as we go through the details.
Pricing and Profit Margins for UK Artists
This is where most artists start and honestly it’s a reasonable place to start. Here’s a rough comparison of typical base prices on the products artists sell most:
| Product | Printful Base Price | Printify Base Price | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| A4 Art Print | ~£5.50 | ~£3.50-£4.50 | Printify |
| A3 Art Print | ~£7.50 | ~£5.00-£6.50 | Printify |
| Framed Print (A4) | ~£22.00 | ~£18.00-£21.00 | Printify (marginally) |
| Canvas (20×16") | ~£28.00 | ~£22.00-£26.00 | Printify |
| T-shirt (Gildan) | ~£14.00 | ~£10.00-£12.00 | Printify |
These are approximate base prices before shipping and they change regularly, especially on Printify where each provider sets its own price. Always check live prices in your account before you set your own retail prices.
On base pricing alone Printify wins almost every category. The reason is simple — they’re aggregating multiple suppliers who compete on price, whereas Printful sets its own rates as a single supplier. Printify also offers a Premium plan with up to 20% off product prices. It’s priced in dollars: $39 a month on monthly billing, or $299 a year (about $25 a month) if you pay annually. If you’re doing any real volume that pays for itself quickly, but for the occasional sale the free plan is the better bet.
But — and this is a big but — base price is only half the story. What really matters is the delivered price to your customer, and where the product actually ships from. That’s where the cheapest option on paper can catch you out.
UK Shipping and Import Charges — This One Matters More Than People Think
As a UK artist selling primarily to a UK audience, where your products are printed and shipped from makes an enormous difference to cost, delivery times and your customer’s experience. This is one area where a lot of artists don’t do enough research before they start.
Printful now has its own UK fulfilment centre in the West Midlands, alongside its European facilities in Latvia and Spain. Products made in the UK facility ship domestically, which means faster delivery and no customs questions for your UK customers. Not every product in the catalogue is made in the UK though, so check the fulfilment location for the specific items you want to sell.
Printify gives you a choice of print providers, including several based in the UK. Pick a UK provider and you get domestic shipping and no customs complications. Prodigi, a UK-based fine art printer, is one of the best known and is available as a Printify provider.
Here’s the catch that a reader rightly pointed out to me. Printify’s cheapest provider for a product isn’t always in the UK. On some products, like larger canvases, the lowest delivered price can come from a supplier shipping from outside the UK. That might save you a few pounds on paper, but the order can take longer to arrive and, depending on the order value and how VAT and duty are handled, your customer could occasionaly face unexpected import charges. Nothing damages repeat sales faster than a customer being asked to pay extra before their print is handed over.
So the rule is simple. When you compare prices, compare the total cost including UK shipping, and check where it ships from. In Printify you can filter print providers by location, so for UK customers I’d start by shortlisting UK providers and only look further afield if the saving is genuinely worth it.
Print Quality — The Honest Truth
I’ll be straight here: print quality is genuinely difficult to compare objectively because it varies by product, by supplier, and even by batch. What I can tell you is what the pattern tends to be.
Printful quality is consistent. Because they control their own production you know roughly what you’re going to get every time. The quality is good — not exceptional, but reliably good. For most artists selling prints online that consistency is genuinely valuable. A customer who orders from you in January and again in August will get the same product both times.
Printify quality is variable. The best Printify suppliers produce excellent results — often better than Printful on certain products. But the worst suppliers are noticeably worse, and if you don’t research your supplier choices carefully you can end up with inconsistent output that damages your reputation with customers. The onus is on you to sample products from your chosen supplier before you start selling. That’s an extra step that Printful doesn’t require.
My recommendation: if you go with Printify, order samples from at least two or three UK suppliers before you commit. The small upfront cost of doing this properly will save you a lot of headaches later.
While you’re thinking about print quality, it’s worth considering the source materials you use for original work too. The better your original artwork file, the better any print will look. We track deals on Jackson’s Art, Cass Art and other major UK retailers if you want to keep material costs down while you’re building your print business. And if you’d rather print at home or use a dedicated fine art printer, my guides to the best printers for art prints and UK giclée printing companies cover the alternatives.
Platform Integrations for UK Artists
| Platform | Printful | Printify |
|---|---|---|
| Shopify | ✅ Excellent | ✅ Excellent |
| Etsy | ✅ Excellent | ✅ Excellent |
| Squarespace | ✅ Supported | ✅ Supported |
| WooCommerce | ✅ Good | ✅ Good |
| Wix | ✅ Supported | ✅ Supported |
| BigCommerce | ✅ Good | ✅ Good |
| TikTok Shop | ✅ Supported | ✅ Supported |
Integrations used to be a real point of difference, but both platforms now connect with all the main shop builders, including Squarespace and Wix. Printful still has the slightly longer list of integrations overall, and it’s worth checking the detail of how each one handles things like product syncing and shipping rates for your particular setup. We’ve written a full Squarespace review for UK artists and an honest look at Etsy vs Shopify for UK artists if you’re still choosing where to sell.
If you’re on Shopify or Etsy, both platforms integrate equally well with both Printful and Printify and the integration choice shouldn’t be a deciding factor.
Product Range
Both platforms have expanded their product catalogues significantly in recent years. For artists specifically the most relevant products are:
- Fine art prints (giclée quality on certain suppliers)
- Framed prints
- Canvas prints
- Art prints on metal or acrylic
- Greeting cards
- Tote bags and apparel with artwork
- Phone cases
- Mugs and homeware
Printify edges ahead on product variety simply because you’re accessing multiple suppliers rather than one. Some niche products — certain paper types, specific framing options, unusual formats — are only available through specific Printify suppliers that Printful simply doesn’t offer.
If you want giclée-quality fine art prints specifically, worth looking at Prodigi through Printify. They’re a Fine Art Trade Guild approved printer and have built a strong reputaion in this space among professional artists. If you’d rather sell through a marketplace that handles everything, my Redbubble vs Society6 comparison is worth a read too.
Customer Service — No Contest
Printful wins this hands down and it’s not close.
When something goes wrong with a Printful order you contact one company. They have a well-documented support process, they respond reasonably quickly, and they have clear policies on reprints and refunds.
When something goes wrong with a Printify order it can get complicated. Printify’s support team are the middlemen between you and the actual supplier. Resolution times can be slower and outcomes more variable depending on which supplier you’re using. I’ve spoken to artists who’ve had excellent Printify support experiences and others who’ve found it genuinely frustrating.
If you’re just starting out and the thought of navigating supplier disputes gives you a headache, that’s a legitimate reason to start with Printful even if the margins are slightly tighter.
Printful vs Printify — Quick Summary
| Category | Printful | Printify | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Base pricing | Higher | Lower | Printify |
| UK fulfilment | Own UK facility for many products | UK providers available (but not always the cheapest) | Draw — check where each product ships from |
| Print quality consistency | Consistent | Variable | Printful |
| Platform integrations | Slightly broader | All the main platforms | Printful (marginally) |
| Product range | Good | Wider | Printify |
| Customer service | Excellent | Variable | Printful |
| Ease of getting started | Easier | More research needed | Printful |
| Profit margins | Tighter | Better (if you pick the right provider) | Printify |
So Which Should UK Artists Actually Choose?
Here’s my genuine recommendation after years of watching artists navigate this decision:
Start with Printful if: You’re new to print on demand, you want to get set up quickly without a lot of research, you value consistency and straightforward customer service over maximum margin, or you want UK fulfilment without having to vet individual suppliers.
Start with Printify if: You’re selling primarily on Shopify or Etsy, you’re willing to put the time in to research and sample UK-based suppliers, you’re focused on maximising profit margins, or you want access to a wider product range including giclée-quality fine art prints.
The advanced move: Use both. There’s nothing stopping you from using Printful for certain products where their quality and integrations are strongest, and Printify for products where a specific UK supplier offers better pricing or quality. Plenty of experienced artists do exactly this.
Whatever you decide, make sure you’re selling your prints alongside keeping your own art supply costs as low as possible. Check our latest art supply deals and our clearance deals page regularly — every pound saved on materials is another pound of margin on your prints. And if you’re framing your best originals for sale, my guide to UK picture framing companies will help.
Get started with Printful free →Get started with Printify free →
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Printful or Printify cheaper for UK artists?
On base product prices Printify is usually cheaper, because its print providers compete on price. But the cheapest Printify provider isn’t always based in the UK, so always compare the total price including UK shipping, and check where the supplier ships from, before deciding.
Does Printful print in the UK?
Yes. Printful has its own fulfilment centre in the West Midlands that serves UK customers, alongside facilities in Latvia and Spain. Not every product is made in the UK, so check the fulfilment location for the specific products you plan to sell.
Can UK customers be charged import fees on print on demand orders?
It can happen when an order is printed and shipped from outside the UK, depending on the order value and how VAT and duty are handled. Choosing a UK-based supplier for UK customers avoids the risk and usually speeds up delivery too.
Is Printify Premium worth it?
Printify Premium gives up to 20% off product prices for a monthly or annual fee. It generally pays for itself once you’re selling a steady number of orders each month, but if you’re only making the odd sale, the free plan makes more sense.
Which is best for fine art prints?
For gallery-quality giclée prints, look at specialist providers. Prodigi, a UK-based fine art printer, is available as a print provider through Printify, while Printful offers consistent quality from its own facilities. Order samples from both before you start selling.
Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. If you sign up to any platform via our links we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend platforms we genuinely believe are useful for UK artists.
