Artist Growth Website Builders for Artists

Big Cartel for Artists — Is It Still Worth Using

May 23, 2026

Big Cartel for Artists — Is It Still Worth Using? | Discount Art Supplies

Written by Paul Worrall

Big Cartel keeps coming up in conversations with artists who want to sell their work online. It’s been around since 2005, it’s cheap, it’s simple, and it’s built specifically for creative people rather than corporate retailers. Those are genuinely appealing qualities. But the art world and the e-commerce landscape have both changed significantly since Big Cartel launched, and the question of whether it’s still the right platform for artists selling online deserves an honest answer rather than a platform comparison that reads like an affiliate review.

I’m Paul Worrall. I spent nearly a decade as Digital Marketing Manager at ARTdiscount, one of the UK’s largest online art retailers, and I now run Discount Art Supplies — a price comparison platform used by tens of thousands of UK artists. I’ve watched a lot of artists navigate the question of where and how to sell their work online. Here’s my honest take on Big Cartel.

What Is Big Cartel?

Big Cartel was founded in 2005 by Matt Wigham — a musician who built the platform because he and his bandmates needed a simple way to sell merchandise online without the complexity and cost of existing e-commerce solutions. That origin story matters because it shaped everything about what Big Cartel is and isn’t. It was built by a creative person for creative people, not by developers trying to replicate what Amazon does at smaller scale.

The platform has stayed remarkably true to that founding philosophy. Big Cartel is not trying to compete with Shopify on features. It’s not trying to replicate Etsy’s marketplace model. It occupies a specific and deliberate position: the simplest possible way for an independent artist or maker to get a store online, take payments, and sell their work without a steep learning curve or a significant monthly bill. Over 65,000 live stores currently run on the platform, which tells you there’s a genuine audience for what it offers.

How Big Cartel Works — The Basics

Big Cartel operates on a tiered pricing model that’s genuinely simple — which is refreshing in a market where pricing pages are often deliberately obfuscating. The free plan allows you to list up to five products with no monthly fee. Paid plans start at around $9 per month for more products, scaling up to $19.99 per month for the highest tier which allows up to 500 products. There are no listing fees and no transaction fees on top of standard payment processing — which is a meaningful differrence from platforms like Etsy that layer fees on every sale.

Setup is genuinely straightforward. You can have a working store with your own branding, a custom domain, and products listed in an afternoon. There’s no coding required, no developer needed, and the interface is clean enough that most artists can navigate it without wanting to throw their laptop out of the window. The themes are minimalist and product-focused — which suits original art and handmade goods better than the busier templates of more feature-heavy platforms like Wix or Squarespace.

Payment processing runs through Stripe and PayPal. Shipping tools are basic but functional — you can set flat rate shipping, offer free shipping, or charge by weight. Discount codes, real-time statistics, and shipment tracking are available on all plans including the free tier.

What Big Cartel Does Well

The honest case for Big Cartel starts with price. If you’re an artist selling a small body of work — original paintings, prints, ceramics, handmade goods — the economics of Big Cartel are hard to argue with. A free plan for five products means you can test whether selling online works for you with zero financial risk. Even the paid plans are priced accessibly enough that the platform cost is not going to meaningfully impact your margins.

The simplicity is a genuine strength rather than a compromise. A lot of artists don’t want to spend their time managing an e-commerce platform. They want to make work, list it, sell it, and get back to making more work. Big Cartel respects that priority in a way that more complex platforms don’t. The absence of endless settings, plugins, and configuration options that characterises Shopify and WooCommerce is not a bug in Big Cartel — it’s the entire point.

The focus on artists and makers rather than generic retail is also real. The themes are designed to showcase visual work. The platform doesn’t try to push you towards features you don’t need. There’s no pressure to run ads, build funnels, or implement marketing automation. For artists who want to pair their store with a proper email strategy, something like Mailchimp or Klaviyo connects via Zapier and handles that side of things separately. For artists who find the commercialisation of creativity uncomfortable, Big Cartel’s stripped-back approach is genuinely refreshing.

The no-transaction-fee model matters more than it might initially appear. Etsy takes 6.5% of every sale on top of listing fees and payment processing. On a £200 original painting, that’s £13 gone before you’ve considered payment processing costs. Big Cartel’s flat monthly fee means your margin on higher-value individual sales is significantly better — which for artists selling original work rather than high-volume prints is an important distinction. If print-on-demand is part of your model, it’s also worth reading our comparison of Printful vs Printify for UK artists before deciding how to structure your store.

Where Big Cartel Falls Short

The honest limitations of Big Cartel are real and worth understanding clearly before you commit to the platform.

The product limit is the most obvious constraint. Five products on the free plan is extremely limiting for any artist with a body of work. The 500-product ceiling on the highest paid plan sounds generous — and for many artists it is — but the fact that the entire platform is structured around product count rather than features means you’re always aware of the ceiling. For artists who produce and sell regularly, running up against those limits is a genuine frustration.

The SEO tools are basic to the point of being inadequate for anyone serious about driving organic traffic to their store. You can set page titles and meta descriptions, but the platform lacks the technical SEO controls that matter for ranking — structured data, canonical tags, advanced sitemap control, proper blog functionality. Having spent sixteen years watching what actually drives traffic to art retail sites, I can tell you that Big Cartel’s SEO limitations are a significant handicap if organic search is part of your traffic strategy. It isn’t built for discoverability — it’s built for people who already have an audience and need somewhere to point them.

The analytics are thin. Real-time visitor stats are available but the depth of reporting is nowhere near what you’d get from a Shopify store with Google Analytics properly integrated. For artists who want to understand where their customers come from, what they browse, and why they buy or don’t buy, Big Cartel doesn’t give you enough to work with. For a deeper look at what a more powerful analytics setup looks like in practice, our Shopify for artists guide covers this in some detail.

There’s no built-in email marketing, no abandoned cart recovery, no upselling or cross-selling functionality, and limited third-party integrations compared to more established platforms. Zapier can bridge some of these gaps but it adds complexity and cost. If you want a platform that grows with your business and supports increasingly sophisticated marketing, Big Cartel will eventually feel limiting. Design tools like Canva Pro or Adobe Creative Cloud can help you produce marketing assets independently of the platform, but the integration is always going to be more manual than on a more sophisticated e-commerce setup.

The theme selection is limited. Minimalism is a deliberate design philosophy for Big Cartel, and the themes reflect that — but if you want a store that feels distinctive and visually rich, your options are constrained. Customisation beyond the built-in theme editor requires coding knowledge that most artists don’t have and shouldn’t need to acquire. Platforms like Format or Pixpa offer considerably more portfolio and design flexibility if visual presentation is your priority.

Big Cartel vs Etsy — The Question Artists Always Ask

This is the comparison that matters most for most artists, and it’s worth being direct about it. We’ve covered the Etsy vs Shopify debate for UK artists separately — but here’s how Big Cartel fits into that picture.

Etsy has a built-in audience of buyers actively searching for handmade and original work. Big Cartel has no marketplace — nobody browses Big Cartel looking for art to buy. When you open a Big Cartel store, you are entirely responsible for driving your own traffic. That distinction is significant. For an artist with no existing audience, Etsy’s marketplace is enormously valuable even at the cost of higher fees. For an artist with an established following — social media, email list, existing customer base — Big Cartel’s economics are considerably more attractive.

The fee structure comparison is stark on individual sales. Etsy’s 6.5% transaction fee plus listing fees plus payment processing adds up to roughly 10-12% of every sale going to the platform. Big Cartel’s flat monthly fee means that on a £500 painting, you keep considerably more of the sale price than you would on Etsy. For artists selling higher-value original work, that difference compounds meaningfully over a year. If print-on-demand is part of your offering, also read our Redbubble vs Society6 comparison for UK artists — passive income from prints changes the platform maths considerably.

The honest answer is that they’re not direct competitors — they serve different situations. Etsy is where you go to find customers. Big Cartel is where you go when you already have them.

Big Cartel vs Shopify — Is the Simplicity Worth the Trade-Off?

Shopify is the other obvious comparison, and it’s a more straightforward one. Shopify is a fundamentally more powerful platform — better SEO tools, better analytics, better integrations, better scalability, better everything at the feature level. The trade-offs are cost and complexity. Shopify starts at £25 a month in the UK and the real cost for a properly functioning store with the apps you actually need is often considerably higher. It also has a learning curve that genuinely puts some artists off.

For an artist who is serious about building an e-commerce operation, treating their store as a business, and investing time in marketing and growth — Shopify is almost certainly the right answer long term. I spent years working with Shopify at ARTdiscount and the platform’s capabilties for a serious retail operation are genuinely impressive. For an artist who wants to sell some work online with minimal fuss and minimal cost, Big Cartel is a legitimate and rational choice. The question is which category you’re in.

If you’re weighing up other website builder options alongside this, we’ve also covered Weebly vs Wix for UK artists and done a full honest Wix review for artists — both worth reading before you make a final decision on platform.

Who Big Cartel Is Actually Right For

Being specific here is more useful than hedging. Big Cartel is a good fit if you are an artist who already has an audience — whether that’s social media followers, an email list, a local reputation, or an existing customer base — and needs a simple, affordable destination to send them to buy your work. It’s the right choice if you sell a relatively small number of products and value simplicity over features. It’s sensible if you’re testing whether selling online works for you before committing to a more expensive and complex platform.

Big Cartel is not the right choice if you’re relying on organic search to drive discovery of your work. It’s not right if you want to build a sophisticated marketing operation around your store. It’s not ideal if you produce work at volume and need a platform that scales gracefully. And it’s not the answer if you want your store to grow into a genuine e-commerce business rather than a simple sales point. If portfolio presentation matters as much as selling, it’s worth comparing Format vs Pixpa or reading our Squarespace for artists review — both cover platforms that do portfolio and selling simultaneously.

The Verdict

Big Cartel is a legitimate, well-made platform that does exactly what it sets out to do. For the right artist in the right situation, it’s genuinely one of the better options available — simple, affordable, honest in its pricing, and built with genuine understanding of what creative people actually need from an online store.

The mistake is expecting it to be something it isn’t. It’s not a discovery platform. It’s not a marketing machine. It’s not going to compete with Shopify on features or Etsy on audience. What it is — a clean, affordable, uncomplicated way for an artist with an existing following to sell their work online — it does well.

If you’re an artist thinking about where to sell your work online, the platform decision matters less than the audience question. Build the audience first — through social media, through your email list, through the kind of community that I’ve spent years building at Discount Art Supplies — and the platform choice becomes considerably less consequential. Big Cartel works perfectly well as the destination for an artist who has already done that work. Without it, no platform will save you.

And whatever platform you choose — the art supplies you use to make your work don’t need to cost you more than they should. Compare prices across all major UK retailers at Discount Art Supplies before you buy.